Two Thumbs Up! Roger Ebert Wins New Yorker Cartoon Caption Contest
RAISING EYEBROWS AND...

Two Thumbs Up! Roger Ebert Wins New Yorker Cartoon Caption Contest
CHICAGO'S VERY OWN MOVIE CRITIC ROGER EBERT HAS MADE A CAREER out of writing short and snappy.
It's an art form, one he has indulged in for 40 years as journalist and movie reviewer. But apparently Ebert has lusted after brighter literary lights -- to see his name in the New Yorker.
And so he has entered the magazine's carton caption headline 107 times -- "which puts him in five hundred and sixty-ninth place out of 502,416 unique entrants, who have submitted a total of 1,595,506 captions," the magazine reveals in a recent piece.
"It’s not that I think my cartoon captions are better than anyone else’s, although some weeks, understandably, I do,'' Ebert wrote two years ago in the Sun Times. "It’s that just once I want to see one of my damn captions in the magazine that publishes the best cartoons in the world. Is that too much to ask?"
Apparently, the answer is no.
The granddaddy of America's literary magazines finally rewards Ebert with a caption win in a cartoon showing a lost couple (presumably) looking for their car in a section marked "F". The wife snipes, "I'm not going to say the word I'm thinking of."
It's cute if a little obvious but doesn't come close to the cleverness of other captions he's submitted including the cheeky one above.
" Well, Roger Ebert certainly has the hang of it now,'' writes Robert Mankoff, the magazine's cartoon editor. "And I see he has entered contest No. 282, so stay tuned."
And now, the peanut balcony is closed.
Tags: Ephemera








Comments
Hi. Bob DiPasquale, self proclaimed caption contest expert here. While I've won Dave Lettermen's online Top 10 contest three times, my continued cracks at the New Yorker always seem to fall short too. I'm an application developer by day, and I approached the New Yorker years ago on how to run a better caption contest. I think it may have been Mr Mankoff himself that agreed my idea had some merit. Alas, he passed though, so I built a web site where members both judge and submit. Every caption gets ranked, and you truly learn how funny you are. I don't have the resources yet to reach the quality found at the New Yorker's contest, but I could at least tell Roger what his HumorQ is. You'll have to be clever to find the site I guess. No spamming here in the comments section.
Posted by: Bob DiPasquale | April 26, 2011 02:40 PM