Home   Buzz   Chicago   Ephemera  Etsy  Politics  Pop Culture  RHBH  RHNJ  RHNY  RHOC  Sex  YouTube  WikiLeaks

FLIP A COIN

Credit: Fox Credit: Fox

Wishful Thinking: Fans of Lee DeWyze & Crystal Bowersox Predict Wins For Their Favorite

By Elizabeth C.

WITH ONLY 24 HOURS TO GO BEFORE THE WINNER OF American Idol is crowned, fans of both finalists can find reason to crow.

Chicago's homeboy (well, Mount Prospect, Ill. is close enough) has already been declared the winner by a Psychology Today blogger, who ticks off a litany of reasons why Lee DeWyze's crowning is inevitable.

Scott Barry Kaufman, Ph.D., a New York-based cognitive psychologist, says Lee has both the "the talent factor and the relatability factor" that make him appealing.

Combine these traits with his growing charisma and confidence on stage, his humility, and his genuine likeability and he becomes someone the public wants to rally around, contends Kaufman.

The shrink-cum-blogger bolsters his argument with several compelling psychological studies.

Pamela Rutledge, director of the Media Psychology Research Center tells Kaufman: "We want the best man or woman to win -- not just the best singer, but the best person. Narratives are the way we make meaning out of life. Idol represents an archetypal narrative: the journey, the quest against all odds." Lee's story allows us to project our own hopes and dreams.”

But not so fast, says MTV’s Ann Donahue, who’s putting her money on Crystal Bowersox for the win.

"Crystal defined the kind of artist she was early on -- and that, plus her compelling backstory, means that she's received a lot of screen time since the show's debut in January,’’ Donahue writes.

Donahue doesn't use any psycho mumbo jumbo to sway readers to her argument. "Sure, Lee DeWyze has come on strong…But Crystal's been so consistent for so long that she's transcended the horserace appeal."

Of course, both Kaufman and Donahue could be guilty of cognitive dissonance: both seem to be rooting for their inevitables.

We’ll find out soon enough who's right.

In what could be a prelude of the outcome, MTV.com asked readers to vote on who they thought would win. With 4,703 votes cast, 58 percent predicted Lee would win.

It’s a tough vote between two talented artists and I don’t want either to lose. Then again, if they’ve reach this point, is that even possible?

Truth be told, Lee seems to want it more these last few weeks. Crystal is so selfpossessed I doubt she'd really care either way.

Tags: Music , Television

Post a comment