Home   Buzz   Chicago   Ephemera  Etsy  Politics  Pop Culture  RHBH  RHNJ  RHNY  RHOC  Sex  YouTube  WikiLeaks

TOUGH LOVE

Credit: <i>Psychology Today</i>

France's Moves To Punish Mental Abuse In Marriage But Who Defines It?

By MzEll

MzEllWITHIN THE NEXT SIX MONTHS, marriage in France is set to become a much more docile affair. The French government is attempting with a new law to decrease the harmful psychological effects of yelling within marriage.

The law will cover any type of rude behavior toward one's spouse including "repeated rude remarks about a partner's appearance, false allegations of infidelity and threats of physical violence." A warning would be given for a person's first documented decibels, with jail being the final repercussion.

There are many critics of the new law both here and in France. While well-intentioned, I find it to be both humorously offensive and ineffective. Who is to say when a conversation stops being a discussion and becomes an assault? Everyone within a marriage interprets things in their own way. If my husband tells me to "Shut Up!," and I then call him a dork, are we arguing or being playful?

Yelling seems to have become the newest guilt-trip of our society. Last October, the New York Times published at article entitled, "For Some Parents, Shouting is the New Spanking." Most everyone knows that it's no longer socially acceptable to spank your children. But what does the current generation raising wee ones do when all the positive reinforcement and time outs stop working? We YELL.

Regardless of who's doing the hollering, the fact is that as the Times' own expert said, "It isn't the yelling per se that's going to make a difference, it’s how the yelling is interpreted."

Here in America, while a few religiously conservative groups still condone spanking, there are no communities that believe in yelling as a child-rearing practice. And surely most couples in cultures worldwide find appalling abuses like that of an Afghanistan man who threw acid on a young girl's face for daring to go to school.

So what is the solution to what the French law describes as the "psychological damage" that occurs within marriages, and by extension, the couple's family?

Working to eliminate the negative stigma of seeking psychological help would be more productive. Enacting another law that's too vague to nail down is not the answer, in my opinion.

One of my husband Christmas gifts was a copy of Anger Management starring Adam Sandler and Jack Nicholson. I think it demonstrated my point pretty well. The entire movie pokes fun at the fact that Sandler's character is stressed out and his wife thinks he needs help. Our culture sees yelling, hollering, and shouting as something that's hilarious to watch but too shameful to deal with. Only when we can accept that we are all flawed psychologically and seek the assistance we need through counseling, drugs, or divine intervention without shame, can "psychological damage" really be undone.

MzEll is a Twilight-obsessed mother of 3 boys living in South Texas. She's hoping in 2010 to figure out what it means to be a grown up.You can read her blog at Cookiemonks.

Tags: Buzz , Ephemera

Comments

Nice write up !!! Wikileaks could probably give us some more background on this one.

Post a comment